June 25, 2025 Astoria Queens – In a development sending ripples through the Queens Catholic community, the Reverend Michael McHugh, 70, a parochial vicar at Our Lady of Mount Carmel in Astoria, has been officially removed from ministry following the substantiation of sexual misconduct allegations involving a minor. The accusations date back more than two decades, to the 1980s.

The decision, announced by the Diocese of Brooklyn, follows a recommendation from the independent Diocesan Review Board, a panel comprising lay individuals and a priest tasked with examining claims of clerical abuse. Bishop Robert Brennan of the Diocese of Brooklyn addressed the parish in a letter, acknowledging the "disturbing and confusing" nature of the news.

Understanding the Church's Action

While church officials have not released the specific details of the alleged transgression, the Bishop emphasized that the Review Board's finding recognizes the gravity of the allegations. "Often just having a place to speak about such matters is a beginning step to addressing the strong impact such news can have," Brennan wrote, highlighting the church's commitment to providing support to the community.

It's crucial to understand that McHugh's removal, known as defrocking, does not equate to a legal conviction. However, it is a significant ecclesiastical penalty, intended as a necessary safeguard to protect church members.

Implications for Father McHugh and the Diocese

Under the terms of his removal, Father McHugh is immediately prohibited from publicly celebrating Mass or performing any public ministerial duties. He is also barred from residing in any parochial residence. Furthermore, his name will be added to the publicly accessible list of credibly accused clergy on the Diocese of Brooklyn website, a measure aimed at transparency and accountability.

McHugh, ordained in 1980, had served at Our Lady of Mount Carmel since 2018. His past assignments included parishes in Flatbush, Jackson Heights, and Long Island City. Despite attempts, Father McHugh could not be reached for comment regarding the allegations or his defrocking.

Photo provided by Google

A Call for Continued Vigilance

The Diocese of Brooklyn received the report alleging sexual abuse of a minor during the 1980s and promptly referred the complaint to the Review Board. Bishop Brennan concluded his message to parishioners with a powerful call to action: "I encourage us all to stay vigilant in our commitment to protecting our children and youth."

This case underscores the ongoing efforts within the Catholic Church to address historical allegations of abuse and implement measures to prevent future misconduct. The Diocese of Brooklyn's swift action, guided by its independent review process, signals a continued commitment to safeguarding its community.

What are your thoughts on how dioceses are handling historical abuse allegations? Share your perspective in the comments below.